Introduction

Foreward

This is a wiki dedicated to the game, Dungeons & Dragons. I began playing D&D just before starting grade X, at the age of 15, in 1979. I fell in love with the game right off — and for me, the game has perpetually evolved. For me, however, it has not evolved in the way it did for everyone else. While the game company and the gaming community became enamoured with the opportunity to play out personal fantasies and pretend to be someone other than who they were, what mattered to me was the world itself. I didn't want to be a different person. I wanted to go to a different place, where I would be me, pitted against the trials and tribulations of that strange new world.

Through the 1980s, as the creators of D&D became personal heroes and the game became inundated with personalized rulesets for running any kind of imaginary character we might want to run, I withdrew to my own designs. I didn't see the process of making a player character like "pimping your ride," the way others did. I felt then, and believe now, that what matters is not what your character is, or who they are, but what they do. The starting character should be an empty shell; a neophyte, knowing nothing about the world, with the barest number of personal experiences ... who then heads out into the campaign to become someone. What I see around me are players who want to roll dice and be someone important right off, without having to game. I think it is silly.

This wiki is dedicated to the ideal that a good game needs solid, well-defined rules: rules for comprehension, rules for interaction and even rules for teamwork. The best gaming rules are those that clearly define the boundaries, and the amount of play that exists within those boundaries. Combat rules should explain how fighting is resolved; how the weapons are used; and the cause and effect of every possible strategy. The game is not found in circumventing these rules, but in deciding which rules are to be employed, in which order and at which time. There are an infinite number of possible combinations in a group of players readying themselves for combat, and an infinite number of possible, unforeseen results. Good, clearly defined rules that cannot be broken do not limit the game! They force players to innovate, rather than wish problems away. This wiki tries to create good rules for as many subjects as can be named.

About This Wiki

I began to create a wiki to manage my extensive and complex house rules — which have, over time, superseded the original game rules as a massive rewrite of old Advanced Dungeons & Dragons. I have been rule-writing since I began to dungeon master the game, 40+ years ago. It began with writing out precedents whenever I made a ruling about something the game books didn't cover. I first assembled those precedents on 8x11 sheets of paper ... and when they became too numerous, I began to organize them by category into binders. I began to actively look for rules in the books that I did not agree with so that I could rewrite them. Today, I look to create rules about everything. In the last decade, I've learned that the best way to organize these rules is to contain them within a wiki. After several iterations, the Authentic D&D Wiki, what you see here, has come about.

If you play D&D, whatever edition you might like to play, you will find only shadows of it here. You will find that I've clung to many formats from original D&D; these never seemed broken to me, so I did not fix them. Instead, I fixed everything else. If your only experience with D&D is 5th edition, then I'm sorry; you're not going to find very much that's familiar in the wiki's content.

To date, I have spent very little time explaining the basics of the game to anyone except for new players whom I run in my own campaign. If you knew nothing whatsoever about D&D, I sould make you comfortable with the game in the space of one session. I've introduced hundreds of people and it's easy — so long as we are face to face. D&D is a hands-on, apprentice-oriented game, which is easily learned by watching other friendly, helpful companions play, and thus find yourself eager to jump in. This is how I learned to play. I did not learn by having someone thrust a rulebook at me and tell me to read it cover to cover. That is something I did after I learned to play, not before. I am, therefore, hesitant to make any promises that this introduction, or any other part of this wiki, will teach the reader "how to play."

Furthermore, I resist any notion that the purpose of this introduction, or this wiki, is to ensure than anyone has "fun." Fun is something we make ourselves; a thing that we learn how to do, when we are inspired by our own thoughts and creativity. Any and every activity that encourages imagination and problem-solving has the potential to be enormous fun for some people, and a dreary bore for others. My goal is to inspire and encourage through the building of glistening, crystal palaces constructed of musing, reasoning and vision. How much fun that readers and users have within the walls of these palaces is none of my affair.

How to Use This Wiki

Whatever edition that dungeon masters use for their game worlds, there will always arise situations that haven't been seen before by the DM or by the players. D&D is a game of innovation; and because it is, the creativity of millions of players will outstrip the paltry efforts of a few thousand game designers. No source can ever hope to foresee or solve the problems of every DM playing in a given weekend, to say nothing of 40 years of play. Sadly, the realities of this dearth are made worse in that most designers do little more than redesign the same wheels over and over, bringing nothing that is essentially new to the game.

This wiki cannot be comprehensive; each day, it will become a little more so, but this lowly host will pass away and turn to dust long before there is any hope that this wiki will help with every possible shortcoming in your game world. Still, what is found here in these pages is sure to be very different from the descriptions and approach that are found elsewhere on the internet. I know, because I've looked. I'm most definitely in another category as regards to my approach to D&D. And so, I can only offer this: that if you've looked elsewhere, and can't find what you want, your best chance to find out-of-the-box thinking is right here. Use the search engine. Best of luck.

And if you find you like my way of thinking, keep reading. My goal with this page is to eventually create an introduction that will enable the neophyte to find their way around the pages included here.

Roles

In the first years after Dungeons & Dragons came on the scene, the problem of how to explain what the game is and how it's played proved to be a conundrum. At the time, it was a game unlike any other game — and though many tried hard to wrap the concept up in a neat and tidy package, it was clear that D&D in its grand complexity would defy a simple explanation. Over time, efforts to describe the game reliably were replaced with efforts to sell the game to newcomers, regardless of accuracy. An aggregate answer arose that D&D was essentially "make believe," a simplification that was instantly understood by all. Unfortunately, it was also a simplification that was dead wrong.

Make believe is a form of unstructured participation which seeks to express a child's whims and desires, almost entirely without restraint or any necessity to take problem solving into account. D&D is a staggeringly complex game in which structures and rules are fused delicately together. D&D is full of barriers and stumbling blocks that are deliberately put in place to frustrate a player's desires.

When a player comes to believe that all their fantasies are there to be fulfilled by the game, only to discover that they must first problem solve and depend upon the whim of a die, and not their own will, the consequence is that the player is made to feel cheated and misled. Rather than appreciating the game's rules, players learn to hate them. Having been told that D&D is a game of escape, they quickly resent every set-back, every expectation that they should solve problems, every moment in which they are expected to show patience. Being promised that D&D is about acting out their selfish wants, they soon begin to act out selfishly whenever those wants are momentarily denied.

As a DM, I do not run my game to fulfill the wishes of my players. I approach the game world as a difficult, dangerous, threatening place, which rewards risk and condemns entitlement. This is true regardless of the fantastic locations, strange creatures, magic items and treasures that are found along the way. Many books and pundits will praise D&D because it provides these things, like a smorgasbord just waiting for the player to come along and scoop them out in large heaps upon their plate. I praise D&D because it does not provide these things easily! Fantastic locations are sheer hell to reach and threatening besides. Strange creatures are not arranged like exhibits in a zoo — they are there to kill you if they can. Magic items are infuriatingly hard to find. And treasures ... these are in the hands of persons and beasts who will hold onto them until they are ripped from their cold, dead hands. The game world as a whole is not friendly; it is not a party; and it absolutely is not about players pretending that something is true just because they would have it so.

Yet that is the message that is sent throughout the game community. The result of that message has been the creation of petulant players who demand more and more of DMs, who feel less and less in control of their games ... and thus, less and less inclined to put up with constant wheedling, ultimatums and clamoring asks from players who expect to do nothing to get their bottle.

Player Character Roles

Though often argued to the contrary, I hold that player characters are not the protagonists of a story. There is no "story," not as a predetermined narrative. The events that take place in the game are, and ought to be, a collection of moments like we experience in real life: things to do, places to go, problems to solve, ambitions to fulfill, all of it accomplished while traversing a winding, unexpected course to which meaning is assigned afterwards but which, in the moment, seems raw and incomprehensible. D&D ought to be about managing and enjoying the immediate, the here and now, with its hilarity, triumph, panic, desperate chance-taking and hope, peppered with relief and the appeal of something accomplished by one's own hand. A story may be diverting; it may have interesting ups and downs; but it is, essentially, only a story.

D&D permits the player to confront events as though they were really happening; the events may be fictional, but the emotions attached to those events are not! Players really can know fear and exhaltation. They may not actually die, but they can feel the honest, prickly sensation of loss and remorse when it happens to their character. Much is made of the dangers of D&D being "too serious" ... yet no one suspends professional sports because a team wins and a hundred thousand fans flood out into the streets to light fires, turn over cars, break windows and start fights. D&D deserves to bring as much joy and bitterness as any other beloved activity, no matter who cannot bear the strain of that relationship.

Therefore, upon creating their characters, players should not expect to be given directions or worksheets as to what is expected of them. They should have precisely what we have in life: a vague understanding of what we are able to do and a clear understanding that if we do not do it for ourselves, we won't survive. And one other thing: an appreciation that, unlike in real life, if our efforts and ambitions, and time spent, explode in our faces and leave us dead and dying on the battle field, it does not mean the end of our gameplay. We can brush ourselves off, value what we've learned, and try again.

Players must understand that their characters are expected to live. Everything else is up to them.