Difference between revisions of "Talk:Catch Fishing (sage ability)"

From The Authentic D&D Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
m
 
(3 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
[[User:Maxwell|Maxwell]] ([[User talk:Maxwell|talk]]) Going by the three-way division you use for [[Athletics (sage study)]] -- Unskilled, Talented, and Skilled -- this ability lacks description for how to resolve fishing by someone who is Talented. I propose a d8 or d10 primary die, and otherwise unchanged from the Unskilled case.
+
[[User:Maxwell|Maxwell]] ([[User talk:Maxwell|talk]]) Going by the three-way division you use for Athletics (sage study) -- Unskilled, Talented, and Skilled -- this ability lacks description for how to resolve fishing by someone who is Talented. I propose a d8 or d10 primary die, and otherwise unchanged from the Unskilled case.
  
−
I don't think your intention has been that, outside of Athletics, the division is only two-way, and "Unskilled" means anything less than 10 pts. Doesn't square with, for instance, what you said to me a few months ago about how you'd rule that a ranger with more than 0 and less than 10 points in Forestry could partially use that study's amateur abilities... [I can already hear you telling me that all work is temporary and lasts only until we have a better idea. ;)]
+
[[User:Tao alexis|Tao alexis]] ([[User talk:Tao alexis|talk]]) I'm not using those three levels as established for every sage ability.  Nor do I intend to. They're fine when they're needed, but I think an extra distinction in this case just creates unessential detail.
 +
 
 +
[[User:Maxwell|Maxwell]] ([[User talk:Maxwell|talk]]) Ah, got it.

Latest revision as of 22:39, 15 October 2023

Maxwell (talk) Going by the three-way division you use for Athletics (sage study) -- Unskilled, Talented, and Skilled -- this ability lacks description for how to resolve fishing by someone who is Talented. I propose a d8 or d10 primary die, and otherwise unchanged from the Unskilled case.

Tao alexis (talk) I'm not using those three levels as established for every sage ability. Nor do I intend to. They're fine when they're needed, but I think an extra distinction in this case just creates unessential detail.

Maxwell (talk) Ah, got it.

Retrieved from "http://wiki.alexissmolensk.com/index.php?title=Talk:Catch_Fishing_(sage_ability)&oldid=24164"