Difference between revisions of "Talk:Companion Animal, Dog (sage ability)"
From The Authentic D&D Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to searchTao alexis (talk | contribs) |
Tao alexis (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
My thoughts go toward mimicking the paladin's warhorse, or the druid's or ranger's animal companions. There can't be too much crossover, mechanically speaking, lest the abilities blend too much together; but one key element would be the player's control over the animal, as though it were a henchman or follower. | My thoughts go toward mimicking the paladin's warhorse, or the druid's or ranger's animal companions. There can't be too much crossover, mechanically speaking, lest the abilities blend too much together; but one key element would be the player's control over the animal, as though it were a henchman or follower. | ||
:Those should not be your thoughts. This is a sage ability; we're not handing the character an instantly fanatically loyal follower. We want to regulate what the dog owner is allowed to do, starting at an early level and working the way up. For example, should the player be allowed to order the dog to kill at first level? We don't want that; the player should not be able to buy a dog with their first money, then have that dog added to their fighting ability. At 1st level, we want to represent what a good dog owner can do: feed the dog, give working orders to the dog, gain the dog's trust, loyalty and friendship; and have the dog as a defender. Military dog training should be reserved for Authority level. | :Those should not be your thoughts. This is a sage ability; we're not handing the character an instantly fanatically loyal follower. We want to regulate what the dog owner is allowed to do, starting at an early level and working the way up. For example, should the player be allowed to order the dog to kill at first level? We don't want that; the player should not be able to buy a dog with their first money, then have that dog added to their fighting ability. At 1st level, we want to represent what a good dog owner can do: feed the dog, give working orders to the dog, gain the dog's trust, loyalty and friendship; and have the dog as a defender. Military dog training should be reserved for Authority level. | ||
| − | ::Were you able to make this page? You shouldn't have that ability. | + | ::Were you able to make this page? You shouldn't have that ability. I already nixed the "companion dog" as a description, and the title of the page is not commensurate with other page names of sage abilities. |
Latest revision as of 16:58, 12 February 2020
My thoughts go toward mimicking the paladin's warhorse, or the druid's or ranger's animal companions. There can't be too much crossover, mechanically speaking, lest the abilities blend too much together; but one key element would be the player's control over the animal, as though it were a henchman or follower.
- Those should not be your thoughts. This is a sage ability; we're not handing the character an instantly fanatically loyal follower. We want to regulate what the dog owner is allowed to do, starting at an early level and working the way up. For example, should the player be allowed to order the dog to kill at first level? We don't want that; the player should not be able to buy a dog with their first money, then have that dog added to their fighting ability. At 1st level, we want to represent what a good dog owner can do: feed the dog, give working orders to the dog, gain the dog's trust, loyalty and friendship; and have the dog as a defender. Military dog training should be reserved for Authority level.
- Were you able to make this page? You shouldn't have that ability. I already nixed the "companion dog" as a description, and the title of the page is not commensurate with other page names of sage abilities.
